L3C and B-Corps

By: Donna Ray Berkelhammer. This was posted Friday, March 4th, 2011

Rate how helpful this article is:
Not HelpfulSomewhat HelpfulPretty HelpfulVery HelpfulExtremely Helpful

(3 votes, average: 4.00 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

Anyone who is at all active in the Triangle business community knows we are a breeding ground for social enterprise – companies that are formed to achieve a social purpose as well as make a living for the founders.  Social entrepreneurs have two cutting edge resources to available to them in North Carolina  — the L3C and the B corporation.  I was quoted today in an article in the Triangle Business Journal about low-profit limited liability companies, known as L3Cs. 

L3Cs are limited liability companies that have both a profit-purpose and a charitable or education purpose.  They were approved by the legislature on August 1, 2010.  About a dozen have been formed to date here.  They are intended to attract investment and funding sources that may not be available to traditional for-profit entities.

Proponents would like the L3C to become the entity of choice for “program-related investments” (known also as PRI) from  private foundations.  Private foundations are required by the IRS to distribute a percentage of their funds each year, either through grants, loans or other investments for mission-related activities (i.e., program-related investments).  Few private foundations make loans or investments because it is cumbersome and regulation-heavy.  It is easier to give outright grants. Because the L3C authorizing statutes contain certain PRI  language from the Internal Revenue Code , proponents hope private foundations will begin considering funding mixed use for-profit/charitable projects by investing in L3Cs. They are lobbying to get federal tax recognition for the PRI investments in L3Cs.

Another cutting edge social enterprise concept is the B-Corporation (“B” standing for Benefit).  Currently, B-corporations are not recognized via a specific statute in North Carolina, but a bill has been introduced in the North Carolina senate to recognize benefit corporations. Companies, however, can voluntarily be certified as B-corporations by B Labs, a non-profit organization.  The impact of being a “B Corp” now is like having a “Good Housekeeping Seal of Approval” — it is a certification from an independent third-party acknowledging your company’s commitment to serving society and the environment.  B Corps do not receive any specific tax breaks at the state or national level. 

Current corporation law is arguably geared toward maximizing profits for shareholders.  The L3C statute and proposed Benefit Corporation statutes are geared at making it acceptable legally for a company to focus on a social goal, perhaps to the detriment of the profit motive.  The L3C statute, for example, clearly states that the company should operate so that “no significant purpose of the company is the production of income or the appreciation of property.” It allows the owner to focus on meeting the social purpose without having to focus exclusively on return on investment.  The company is in no way prohibited from being profitable; it should not be the main focus.

 It is thrilling as a lawyer to be involved at the inception of a new entity — particularly one that will help people “do well by doing good.”

Tags:


Comments:

  • [...] David Zaring posted about this interesting story. Here is a small section of the postThis entry was posted on Friday, March 4th, 2011 at 4:04 pm and is filed under Corporate management, Durham, North Carolina Statutes, business law, formation, small business. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS … [...]

    Posted by: Bankruptcy Top Stories Tomorrow » Blog Archive » L3C and B-Corps | North Carolina Law Life | March 7th, 2011 at 6:20 pm
     
  • Wonderful article! I was one of the first to form an L3C in North Carolina, and after weighing the current options, am about to form another L3C (the two ventures are symbiotic).

    I’m especially enamored of co-ops but find both nonprofits, and the parameters required to form a co-op, incredibly restrictive. As a lifelong social entrepreneur, I believe we can be transparent willingly (hence the B-Corporation certification), but the red tape of most of the legal entities is very restrictive. I’m thinking that, when I progress to creating co-op enterprises, they should also be done as an L3C. I hope others have more experience by then to guide me regarding co-ops and L3C’s. :)

    Thanks again,

    Dena

    Posted by: Dena Patrick | March 21st, 2011 at 12:59 pm
     
  • In addition, North Carolina law is quite limited in what can be a co-op. I’ve had to force clients with co-op business plans from other states into ill-suited LLCs here, because our co-op laws are so restrictive compared to other places. For example:

    § 54‑111. Nature of the association.

    Any number of persons, not less than five, may associate themselves as a mutual association, society, company, or exchange, for the purpose of conducting any agricultural, housing (including apartment housing), horticultural, forestry, dairy, mercantile, mining, manufacturing, telephone, electric light, power, storage, refrigeration, flume, irrigation, water, sewerage, or mechanical business, or purchase, maintain and use fire‑fighting equipment, or for any other lawful purpose, on the mutual plan. For the purposes of this Subchapter, the words association, company, corporation, exchange, society, or union shall be construed to mean the same; provided that the membership of agricultural organizations incorporated under this Subchapter shall consist of producers of agricultural products, handled by such organizations or by organizations owned and controlled by such producers.

    So, co-op grocery stores are permitted under the agricultural products part of the statutes, but a house cleaning business where the workers own part of the company in a cooperative manner was not able to be formed under our co-op statute.

    Good luck with your businesses.

    Posted by: Donna Ray Chmura | March 29th, 2011 at 8:20 am
     
  • [...] View original post here….[...]…

    [...] Read the rest of this post here[...]…

    Posted by: Joomla Hosting | June 14th, 2011 at 5:05 pm
     

Leave a Reply